Dec 10, 2008


The western and the US media has been rather measured in its castigation of Pakistan on its tacit if not active support to terror strikes in India. Spokespersons of various countries as also the western media are tying themselves in knots trying to be diplomatically correct as also putting the right amount of pressure on Pakistan to clean up its act.

            However Patrick French the UK based writer and the author of ‘The World is what it is’ the official biography of V S Naipaul, has lambasted Pakistan in his piece in the New York Times. Read excerpts from his article below.

They Hate Us — and India Is Us

Published: December 8, 2008

AS an open, diverse and at times chaotic democracy, India has long been a target for terrorism. From the assassination of Mohandas Gandhi in 1948 to the recent attacks in Mumbai, it has faced attempts to change its national character by force. None has yet succeeded. Despite its manifest social failings, India remains the developing world’s most successful experiment in free, plural, large-scale political collaboration.

The Mumbai attacks were transformative, because in them, unlike previous outrages in India, the rich were caught: not only Western visitors in the nation’s magnificent financial capital but also Indian bankers, business owners and socialites. This had symbolic power, as the terrorists knew it would.

However, I recently saw a televised forum in which members of the public vented their fury against India’s politicians for their failure to act, and it soon became apparent the victims were poor as well as rich. One survivor, Shameem Khan — instantly identifiable by his name and his embroidered cap as a Muslim — told how six members of his extended family had been shot dead. Still in shock, he said: “A calamity has fallen on my house. What shall I do?” His neighbors had helped pay for the funeral. Like most of India’s 150 million Muslims, Mr. Khan is staunchly patriotic. The city’s Muslim Council refused to let the terrorists be buried in its graveyards.

When these well-planned attacks unfolded, it was clear to anyone with experience of India that they were not homegrown, and almost certainly originated from Pakistan. Yet the reaction of the world’s news media was to rely on the outmoded idea of Pakistan-India hyphenation — as if a thriving and prosperous democracy of over a billion people must be compared only to an imploded state that is having to be bailed out by the I.M.F. Was Pakistan to blame, asked many pundits, or was India at fault because of its treatment of minority groups?

Read the full article.


  1. I backtracked here from Indiblogger.

    I have started a webring for bloggers who wants to voice their concerns and thoughts. This is a way of linking blogs in a never ending chain. I love my India - I am looking for bloggers who shares the same passion. My own little effort hoping it may be of some worth to the wider cause.
    I am an amateur web designer, and like all my projects this will always remain free to use. No spam, no ads.

    Would you like to join, it is very easy -

  2. I followed the link to your site from your comment on my blog - and was thinking, 'maverickindian' seems familiar.

    Now I know why. :)

  3. @littleindian
    Thanks a lot for stopping by. I could not figure out how maverickindian seems familiar to you. And what do I have to do to join I would love to join.


Thank you very much for taking time off for your comments. It means a lot to me. Do visit again.